You know what, I think what really put all of us off was how different it all was. The characters for starters, the dynamics between them, even the light.

The episode was far from perfect - the supernatural plot was weak at best - and a lot of things were left unsolved, but it is the first episode of a new narrative arc and this is fine in my book. What I really found... idk... overwelming was Dean's grief.

Anyway, I have a lot to say about this episode and I'm too tired right now to do that (I'll post my review, hopefully, tomorrow) but the thing is I watched it three times already and every time I love it a little more.